Part of Temporal Constructs Main Text, which states the research questions, the proposals, the work done and what is still open.

General definition

A position is a claim that a researcher states, or a question that a researcher leaves open. A claim is a statement that can be tested against evidence, and an open question is one that cannot be answered yet.

Relation to the practice

These positions are Gardner‘s own claims and open questions. They are grouped by what they concern: how an artist and a machine work together, what collaboration does to thinking, how the work sits in culture and history, and how the research is conducted. Each group has its own section below, and every position has a page of its own.

Artist and machine

An artist and a machine can meet inside the same instrument. An AI agent can inhabit the rules of an instrument that was written for people. An instrument of that kind works like a game, whose rules can be known while what happens inside them cannot be predicted. Working in that way requires shared competence, which is to say that the artist and the agent know the same language and share the same expertise. The relation between them calls for mutual adaptation. Each side accommodates the other only in part. It stays an open relation, whose terms are settled as the work goes on. One question remains open: whether a machine can once again be given undivided attention in music, the way a game still is.

Collaboration and thinking

Collaboration changes the thinking of the person doing it. It can extend the artist’s own thinking or take that thinking over, which is the difference between thinking with and thinking for. An error can become useful, depending on what the artist intended. Knowledge and terminology open possibilities and also lock thinking into a particular mode, which is the effect the research calls imprisonment by knowledge.

Culture and history

The work sits in a history and a culture, and these positions describe both. Generative artificial intelligence can cut the connection between a maker and an audience, which is the severance the position names. Social and economic conditions push people to hand tasks over to machines, which is the pressure to delegate. The personal computer began as an interactive mirror for the mind and became mainly a tool for reproducing the studio, a turn from mirror to studio. Heritage stays alive through use. Storage alone does not keep it alive, and that is what the position calls heritage as living practice. Development does not advance in a straight line of improvement, so a change removes or makes unavailable as much as it adds, which is the premise of non-linear progress.

Positions on method

These positions concern the research and how it is conducted. Whether artificial intelligence is a genuine other, whose otherness is real and not a reflection of the researcher’s own intentions, remains an open question. The layer that translates between systems is itself a place where research happens, which is the view of the interface as research site. The research also states the terms on which it uses artificial intelligence, in its guidelines for the use of AI.