Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.

General definition

An essay by Mark Bernstein, published by Eastgate Systems in 1998, on how large hypertexts should be shaped so that readers stay and explore. It is the essay generally credited as the first to use the garden as the figure for a linked body of writing.

Relation to the practice

Bernstein reexamines what he calls the navigation problem. Early research held that hypertexts would enmesh readers in a confusing tangle of links, and the remedies were many navigational tools, simple links, fewer links and very rigid organisation. Experience showed that readers were not getting lost, that occasional disorientation is common in serious writing, and that muddled writing was more likely to be the cause of confusion than the complexity of the links. He sets the garden as a cultivated middle ground between rigid structure and wilderness. Rigid structure is costly, because it hides a hypertext’s message and pushes its content away, while a garden invites visitors to linger, to explore and to reflect. That is the figure Living archive uses for this archive, which is read by curiosity rather than by a route.

Verification

Read in full: the complete essay, 60 pages, held as a PDF from a 2002 capture of the 1998 publication. The passage this page rests on is the section on the navigation problem, which states that readers were not getting lost and that muddled writing was more likely to be the source of confusion than hypertextual complexity, and the fourth section, which opens with the sentence quoted below. Bernstein’s own claim is about how a hypertext should be shaped. The word garden stands for a cultivated middle ground rather than for archives or for gardens in the literal sense.

Gardens are farmland that delights the senses; parks are wilderness, tamed for our enjoyment.

The PDF is filed in Zotero’s literature collection for theory and method.