Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.
General definition
Literature here means the published work a research project reads and argues with, as distinct from the field it contributes to. A project keeps its sources together so that a claim can be traced to the work it rests on, and so that the work can be checked against its original.
Relation to the practice
The doctorate draws its definition of creative intelligence from Tim Ingold, for creativity as an improvisational process of correspondence, and from Gordon Pask, for intelligence residing in the interaction between participants. The sources it reads are listed below, and each is cited on the pages that use it. All of them are to be compared with their originals before citation.
Cited works
Every work cited is kept as a page of its own, recording what it is and what this professional doctorate borrows from it: Barthes 1967 and Foucault 1969 on authorship, Latour on the agency of non-human actors, Sternberg 1985, Hallam and Ingold 2007 and Ingold 2013 on creative intelligence, Russell and Norvig on the definition of an agent, Davis 2013 on human-computer co-creativity, Sweller 1988 on cognitive load, Moran and Carroll 1996 on design rationale, and Lincoln and Guba 1985 on transferability.
The tradition of the laboratory is cited from its own institutions: V2_ 2016 on unstable media and the laboratory as an autonomous zone, Montgomery 2013 on STEIM and instrument design as research, Stubbs 2018 on the Zodiak Free Arts Lab, Marshall 2008 on the BBC Radiophonic Workshop, Rauschenberg Foundation, Art and Technology (n.d.) on Bell Laboratories and Experiments in Art and Technology, Wired 2016 on the Media Lab’s antidisciplinary research, and Terstiege 2021 on the Kling Klang studio of Kraftwerk. The software lineage is cited from the makers: Puckette 2002 on Max at IRCAM, Bernstein, Thirty Years of Non-Stop Flight (n.d.) on the Center for Contemporary Music at Mills College, and Polansky, Burk and Rosenboom 1990 on the design intent of HMSL. The present-day laboratory is cited from its own site, Thunderboom, Music Tech Innovation Lab (n.d.). The Dutch laboratory is cited from the company’s own history and from an author: Schippers, NatLab (Inventing Europe, n.d.) on the NatLab, Philips, Our history (n.d.) on the company’s account of it, and Gardner, Phonogram in de jaren '60 (2012) for the thesis on the Phonogram studio. The Dutch line of electronic music is cited from V2 and from the institute that continues it: [[V2, Chronology of Dick Raaijmakers (n.d.)]] for Raaijmakers at the laboratory, Institute of Sonology, Timeline (n.d.) for the dates of the studio and its transfer, and Institute of Sonology, Mission (n.d.) for the three elements of its identity.
The literature of the research plan is listed alongside them: Roads 2015 on constraints that open creative territory, Sennett 2008 on craft as knowledge held in the hand, Borgmann 1993 on devices that grow more commodious and more opaque, Magnusson 2009 on instruments as epistemic tools, Pasquale 2015 on the black box, Norman 1988 on perceived affordance, and Spiegel 2002 on what disappears with a generation of creative technology. Its methodological literature sits here too: Candy 2006 on the form of a practice-based doctorate, Frayling 1993 on research through art and design, Borgdorff 2012 on artistic research and the accountability it owes, and the Brundtland Report 1987 on sustainability. The method of experimentation is cited from the philosophy of science, where Steinle 1997 names exploratory experimentation and Stojanović 2013 sets out its guidelines. The research works from an archive of the same kind: Muzines, the searchable collection of music technology magazines of the period, written by practitioners for practitioners. Recent studies are on the same footing: Doshi and Hauser 2024 and McGuire and others 2024 on what generative assistance does to creative work, Singh and others 2025 on what the field of co-creative systems has built and what it has left out, and Mahowald and others 2024 on the difference between a model’s fluency and its competence.
Accounts held for the research are kept the same way: the interview with Rosenboom, Gardner and Rosenboom 2026; the licensing arrangement that brought Gardner‘s catalogue into a commercial model, ElevenLabs and Merlin 2025; the published estimate of what generative models cost creators, CISAC 2024; and the announcement that first set out what the research is for, Inholland, AI as a creative instrument (2025); the essay heard inside ALTERITY, Alterity narration (2026); and the deck that states what RETRIEVAL is for, RETRIEVAL, concept deck (2026); beside the one pager for the consortium the research group is convening, Fostering Creative Agency, one pager (2026); and the proposal the trajectory rests on, Gardner, PD proposal (2025); beside the reading material published for the work’s week at the film festival, ALTERITY, Storyspace reading material (2026); and the dated log of the doctorate’s own activity, Gardner, PD activity log (2026).
The documents of the programme are held the same way. What is stated here about the doctorate can be traced to the paper it comes from: the national description of the professional doctorate, Vereniging Hogescholen, UAS Professional Doctorate (2021); the proposition for the third-cycle pilot in the arts and creative sector, Vereniging Hogescholen, PD Kunst + Creatief programmavoorstel; the programme description for Arts + Creative, UAS PD Programme Arts + Creative (2021); the study guide for 2026 to 2027, PD Arts + Creative Study Guide 2026-2027; and the assessment framework the Graduate Committee established in September 2026, PD Arts + Creative Assessment Framework (2026).
The documents of the research itself are held the same way. The application that preceded the doctorate is Stompff, Levelling the playing field (2025), which sets out the co-performance of an artist and a model in an earlier form. It was made in April 2025, and it was not awarded.
A further group of sources is cited on the pages that use them: Candy on practice-based research, Hutchins on distributed cognition, Clark and Chalmers on the extended mind, Magnusson on instruments as knowledge, Gibson and Norman on affordance and constraint, Akrich on the intentions designers embed in objects, Suchman on the tension between plan and situated action, and Rosa on social acceleration. The two reviews of 1991, Trask on the Oberheim Strummer and Sound On Sound on the Drummer and the Strummer, are cited where those two modules are described.