Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.

General definition

The first review of a Professional Doctorate candidate, held in month nine of the trajectory or its part-time equivalent, which forms the view of the candidate and of the committee before the go/no-go assessment in month twelve.

Relation to the practice

The review rests on a report. In that report the candidate compares activities and outcomes to the Research Plan, the Training and Supervision Plan and the learning goals. It also rests on a joint meeting of the committee, whose written advice is then discussed with the candidate in person. At 0.8 full-time equivalent (FTE) the ninth month falls in the eleventh, so the review arrives in November and leaves months ten and eleven for improvements before the assessment.

Procedure of the review

Each supervisor writes an individual written reflection of between 100 and 400 words. The candidate chooses the medium and the format of the report in agreement with the supervisors, and here that form is a presentation. Progress goes to the whole supervisory team on 24 November 2026, sent ahead of the meeting as preparation. The meeting is where the work is elaborated and the questions are answered, with the demonstration of CONDUCTOR and the account published as a wiki shown beside the report. The review sits inside the assessment process. The schedule of the team opens that process with the invitation of 16 November 2026.

Argument of the report

The comparison needs a shape for the year that the plan did not draw, and that shape is engineering. The first two modes were worked in full: the recovery of the orphaned languages, and the interfaces whose constraints make a model collaborate and not dominate. The modes that bring in other practitioners belong to the later years, so the setting aside of the educational commitments in April 2026 is put forward as sequencing. Transfer to others is responsible only once the behaviour of a system is understood by whoever hands it on. In place of teaching, the year offered the public presentation of the work: the premiere, the masterclass, the talks, the magazine and the guided tour.

Two further arguments are made explicit. The first is that the phenomenon the thesis claims, the redistribution of creative agency, is not readily studied at a distance. It was experienced in this year by the artist working inside the constraint languages with agents, and the system that was built makes it observable. The second is that the object of study moved faster than any plan could. The capability of the agents changed repeatedly within the year.

That understanding was won empirically, and the later modes of the plan could not be built on a substrate that was still moving. Named with the arguments are the exposed claims. The pioneer interviews are fewer than the plan assumed, and the criteria by which the work will be evaluated are not yet stated. The evidence so far comes from one practitioner, which is where transferability has to answer.

Grounds of the defence

The course of the year is defended on these grounds together, because the departure from the plan was a dated response. The proposal was written in 2025 without an agent that could build its own tools, and what made that possible arrived in April 2026. From that point the agent, CONDUCTOR and the way of working of the practice changed together. The modes were worked in an order the plan did not draw, and the technical year came before the educational ones.

Put to the committee, the argument is that a doctorate on how creative agency is shared with artificial intelligence cannot fix its method in advance of that capability. What makes the response auditable is the account of when it changed and why, which this entry and the record carry. The unintentional results are noted as findings in their own right. Chief among them is that the practice now runs on tools it owns and can read. The year also produced a working rule about agent claims that no plan anticipated.

A third motive is the practice’s own. The year was also how the artist found out what a model can do for his own work, and which forms of expression it opens. A practice-based doctorate treats that as an outcome in its own right.

Unforeseen

Here the unforeseen situations, sometimes difficult, sometimes unexpectedly interesting, will be described as the project runs. Many of these unforeseen situations have already occurred and have been recorded. They will be added in the time to come.