Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.
General definition
In qualitative research, the extent to which findings from one context apply in other contexts. The reader judges this extent from a sufficiently detailed description (Lincoln and Guba, 1985).
Relation to the practice
The term is used in a more practical sense, and it asks whether the practice can be taken up by other practitioners without specialist knowledge of the instruments. It is the subject of the fourth subsidiary question.
The practice is tested through workshops and masterclasses treated as sites of evidence, through open tools and documentation, and through partners who reach distinct communities of musicians and media artists. A bounded command language also lets smaller AI models operate the system, so access does not depend on expensive infrastructure.
Precedent in the period
The question of who can take up a practice is as old as the software it studies. Manuals and magazine reviews were where the public met the experimental software of the MIDI era. The spread of that software is an early case of a practice becoming available without specialist knowledge, and of well-represented information becoming usable. That history sets the standard for the documentation this research produces. It is why the strand treats the manual as part of the interface.
Recipient groups
The practice addresses three groups in turn. What transfer means differs for each group. For practitioners who already work with legacy hardware, transfer means handing over a working framework, and their own instruments then decide how it is used. For students who already work in electronic music, transfer means adding agents to a practice they have, and the test is whether the additions stay inspectable. Students beginning the subject get a system built on the fundamentals, with the hardware chosen to explain the concept. A practice that began with expensive and obscure machines can therefore be an entry into them.
I target anyone who works with MIDI, but also the pioneers themselves, to offer collaboration on this kind of development, and the audiences that visit my installations to provide AI culture that is often missing (the reason why many people are negative about AI). I intend to nuance this perspective, and show how AI can also be used in a symbiotic human focused way. More focused on the creative process, so the creative artists and their experience, but also on the connection audiences find with the creators.
artist statement
Sequencing of dissemination
The promise of this strand is met at the end of the work, because what is to be handed on has to exist first. The years so far have gone into building the system and into first-hand experience of it. The editor of Trip-A-Tron needed an autonomous navigation and verification layer before an agent could compose in it. The Atari ST needed tools able to read its screen, which is prototyping and not dissemination.
What has been shared so far has been through public talks and demonstrations, and not through teaching. The Tiger Talk at the IFFR premiere, AI in Muziek in Nijmegen and Human After All? in Rotterdam were all outside Inholland. The teaching inside the institution is the masterclass In Conversation with Your Instrument at the Haarlem conservatory in 2026.
The course the practice taught in Antwerp in 2022 comes from the years before the doctorate. There it counts as experience brought into the work, outside the teaching the programme assesses. The balance is expected to change once the framework is handed to others. Part of that plan is to bring the makers of the present into contact with the pioneers of the period, in symposia where the two meet. The protocols and the technology of that time are of use to those building now. The people who made them deserve the recognition.
Unforeseen
Here the unforeseen situations, sometimes difficult, sometimes unexpectedly interesting, will be described as the project runs. Many of these unforeseen situations have already occurred and have been recorded. They will be added in the time to come.