Part of Temporal Constructs Appendix, which contains details behind the research: dates, quotations, descriptions of instruments, and sources.
General definition
The formal assessment after twelve months of a Professional Doctorate, or its part-time equivalent, at which the supervisory committee decides whether the candidate continues, advised by the graduate committee.
Relation to the practice
The assessment takes the go/no-go form, the Training and Supervision Plan and the Research Plan as its source documents. It sets the first year against the learning goals through the four roles, and it may lead to new arrangements that are recorded in the plan.
At 0.8 full-time equivalent (FTE) the twelfth month falls in the fifteenth, which places the assessment in the early months of 2027, about three months after the first-year review.
Outcome
The outcome decides whether the doctorate continues. A decision to continue sends the adjusted report and the evaluations to the graduate committee, and it informs the human resources office of the school. A decision to discontinue ends the contract. A go is also what opens the amendments that the later years rest on.
Assessment dates
The supervisory team set out the process, and it runs from the invitation to the Graduate Committee. The review of 24 November 2026 therefore falls inside the process, and the invitation is issued on 16 November 2026. The steps are:
- The candidate is invited on 16 November 2026 to prepare the report.
- The draft is complete on 11 December 2026.
- The draft is discussed with the supervisors on 15 December 2026.
- The final report goes to all supervisors on 15 January 2027.
- Each supervisor writes an individual evaluation of 100 to 400 words on 18 January 2027.
- The joint assessment meeting and the decision fall on 20 January 2027.
- The form is completed on 22 January 2027.
- The complete dossier reaches the Graduate Committee on 25 January 2027, and it is discussed there on 5 February 2027.
First-year conditions
Preparation for the assessment began in April 2026, when the practice was inventoried in full and mapped to six deliverables, a framing piece and Documents A to F. A month-by-month plan runs to the decision itself, with a focus map of the layers on which the work has to be shown. That preparation also settled that the educational commitments of the programme could not be met yet, and it revised the research question once more. What the assessment reads are the deliverables: the practice is the evidence, and the plan is only the statement of what it was meant to produce.
The assessment is made on two deliverables, the interactive demonstration of CONDUCTOR and the archive published as a wiki, with a short report framing them that goes to the supervisors. The six labelled documents were replaced by these two in November 2026. What the labels covered largely survives in another form.
The technical document is now the demonstration itself and the pages that document the system. The practice appears as the instrument chain in the demonstration and in the pages of the works. Evidence sits in the decision record shown over the demonstration, and preservation and field contribution live in the languages shown in use and the published tools. Transferability is a system that another practitioner can install and run, and conduct and ethics are in the report and the account. The programme’s own paperwork is not part of this and is unchanged. It holds the Training and Supervision Plan with the teaching contribution and the ten EC of individual training, the supervision logs, the curriculum files and the data management plan.
First-year gaps
A review of the first progress report in May 2026 found it strong in argument and short of the explicit self-reflection and methodological accountability that the form requires. The following months had to supply that. In September 2026 the form itself was used to judge readiness. It found the work substantively ahead of what the form requires. What is required is a credible trajectory and not finished research.
The gaps it named were evidential and administrative. They were the logs of the supervision meetings and the courses mapped to the training and supervision plan. They were also a comparison of what was proposed with what was achieved, in which dissemination was the weakest part.
Its advice was to present every change to the research question as a dated decision with its reason attached, and the record and the question page now do exactly that. Comparing the plan of 2025 with the practice of 2026 named three gaps that the first year has not closed. The interviews with the pioneers are fewer than the plan assumed, and the criteria by which the work will be evaluated are not yet stated. The evidence so far comes from one practitioner, and transferability has to answer for that. Read against the learning goals and the four roles, the evidence of the year falls unevenly. The assessment states that unevenness in the report itself.
As Researcher the method is transparent and the account auditable, and as Innovator the intervention is the system itself and the shared command grammar it runs on. In the Professional role the year produced an ethics text and a rule about evidence that is followed in practice. As Change agent the claim is the weakest, because change beyond the field waits on the practitioners that the later modes bring in. The same preparation named the principal risk to the work. It is that the historical framing remains decorative, present in the prose without supporting the argument.